Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant in Surprise

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant in Surprise
4.2
50reviews
View phone 16235375900

18795 N Reems Rd Ste 112, Surprise, AZ 85374-8686, Surprise

Overview

Restaurant Hours

Monday

08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday

08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday

08:00 - 17:00

Thursday

00:00 - 17:00

Friday

00:00 - 17:00

Questions and answers

View all q&a

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
FM

Francisco Martinez

google
11.21.2024
5/5

Great Sicilian pizza by the slice. Perfectly spiced and flavored bread.. I was so used to Gina's Sicilian pizza in St Charles and after they closed I had no I idea where another authentic mom and pop Sicilian pizza place was.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
JG

Joaquin Gerard Cordero

google
11.24.2018
2/5

I was really looking forward to trying this place out... my girlfriend and I did. Unfortunately there was more bad things than good.The food its not bad tasting but they seem to use the cheapest ingredients they can find and it shows when you eat the food, also its a self service joint (just so you are aware).(Pictures below)The interior its not bad looking but man its hot in there! I was sweating the whole time I was eating there. They have no A\C I'm guessing because of the big ovens. Ribs lack of seasoning but they do fall off the bone so easy( the only good thing) the BBQ sauce taste like Tapatio sause and vinegar.Pizza is nothing special if fact is one of the worse ones I've had.Lasagna was really soupy and it barely had any Ricotta cheese in it( the best part of lasagna is the Ricotta) the pasta was almost translucent didn't seem like a good quality pasta.Garlic bread and fries (unsalted) were ok but again low quality. Customer service was ok I've had worse.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
RF

Robert Fisher

google
10.24.2018
5/5

Terrific pizza! Excellent crust, sauce and great ingredients.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
JK

Jill Knuth

google
10.17.2018
5/5

Best pizza in town!!!!

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
RC

Rachel Coons

google
09.17.2018
1/5

Found a huge hair inside the pizza... The pizza itself was nothing special. With all the other great local pizza places in the area, i would not reccomend this one!!

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
TP

T P

google
08.19.2018
1/5

I wanted pizza fast so I stopped by to get two slices of cheese pizza. Guy waits until AFTER he charges me to tell me it’s going to be a 15-20 minute wait for the slices.. that’s something that should have been mentioned before I paid. I said I’d do sausage instead so he wanted to charge me the extra 56¢ for the sausage. Why would I pay for an ingredient I don’t even want and I plan on picking off anyway? He didn’t apology or anything. Needless to say I won’t be back.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
DG

Daniel Gordon

google
08.01.2018
1/5

Ordered 2 slices of pepperoni pizza. They took 2 cold slices of cheese pizza from the pizza warmer, that looked like it wasn't even on, slapped pepperoni on it, and re-warmed them. Pizza tasted like it could have been at least a day old. Burnt cheese on the bottom, and no flavor. Judging by the empty dining area, and the brain-dead staff, I should've known this place was a bust.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
KB

Ken Bainton

google
07.26.2018
3/5

Food was good but overpriced in my opinion.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
MB

Michelle Bocik

google
07.22.2018
1/5

Order two "eggplant" panini sandwiches. Disgusting! More like eggplant spread with some odd unhealthy lunch meat. Panini bread was dripping in grease. First and only time my family and I will ever order from this place again. My dogs wouldn't even eat it!

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
rW

robbin Warren

google
07.04.2018
5/5

Good pizza my mom love and me too

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
CC

Christie Cepero

google
06.08.2018
4/5

This is by far the tastiest and most authentic tasting thin crust pizza I've tasted since I moved to the burbs. You can tell by smell, that the sauce is going to be delicious. The only reason I didn't give them 5 stars is because they are not particularly friendly. No smiles, no chit chat. All business. Definitely not welcoming, but the pizza is great.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
MS

Marcin Szymoniak

google
05.22.2018
5/5

Local pizzeria with Italian touch. Their special pizza is made of tasty ingredients and makes you come back and order it again.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
ML

Monica Lovely

google
05.04.2018
5/5

I grew up with this pizza location. I love the food and the owner is amazing!

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
JS

Josh Swiderski

google
03.25.2018
5/5

Our go to. Top notch!

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
TR

Terry Reed

google
02.22.2018
5/5

We love little sicily. They have great slices or can order a pizza! The employees are super nice too! We have been going here for awhile!!

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
JH

Jeffrey Hamilton

google
01.26.2018
5/5

My daughter and I get the cookies here quite often and pizza sometimes great family feel

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
JB

Jennifer Boucher

google
11.27.2017
1/5

I use to love it!!! For 30 years me and my friends have been ordering from you, and my son has now been coming at least once a month for a year. Today you refused him a cup of water unless he paid $0.50. This is after I called and ordered and paid for a small cheese pizza over the phone! You are jerks!!! The stupidest thing just cost you our business, his friends business and hopefully a few others after I post it on social media!

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
ML

Michael Lazzar

google
11.25.2017
5/5

Been going here since I was basically born, order there every Friday and am always refreshed by their pizzas. Very nice staff, constantly recommend these guys to friends/family.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
ds

dudley skala

google
11.08.2017
5/5

great food good prices they even know my name before i tell them better then any resturants in the area

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
ss

sublime solutions

google
11.05.2017
5/5

I love these guys, family owned and Made! Try the pastry puffs as an appetizer their amazing

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
MJ

Michael James

google
10.19.2017
5/5

Little Sicily has been a family favorite of ours for over 25 years! John and his family make you feel like family. Even though I moved out of the area, they still know who I am when I call or stop in for a pizza. They always ask how I’m doing and how my family is. AMAZING food and great prices! I will always be a customer for life! Best pizza in the country!

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
YR

Yvette Reinke

google
09.23.2017
5/5

This place HANDS DOWN has THE BEST Chicken Tenders in the world! They are super nice too. Love it!!

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
LH

Leo Hamilton

google
09.08.2017
5/5

This place clearly knows how to serve their clients. Regularly with a super friendly demeanor. The food is conveniently priced, regularly yummy and neat.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
TR

Thomas R

google
08.18.2017
5/5

Pizza is the best for this area. I lived in Chicago my whole life and when I moved to the west suburbs it was really hard to find a good pizza joint. This pizza has all the works. Great sauce and a good choice of meat to throw on the pizza. Trust me you will enjoy it.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
CM

Clarence Mullen

google
07.27.2017
5/5

Great pizza. Friendly owner and great delivery guy.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
PD

Patriot Dana

google
07.11.2017
5/5

All fresh. They make thier own sause. This guy is old school. Best pizza. Super nice people. They treat you like family. They have a passion for their food.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
HJ

Hashim Jeelani, Esq

google
06.27.2017
5/5

This is hands down the best pizza you will get in the suburbs... get the double dough, you won't regret it. Tip: Grab a slice from the pizza by-the-slice container while you wait for your pizza...the heated container does something magical to the pizza🤤

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant

M

google
06.08.2017
5/5

I tried this place because of the great reviews. I agree, the pizza is fantastic. It reminds me of the pizza I grew up having in the city. I will definitely be ordering from here again.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
DA

David Alvarado

google
06.08.2017
2/5

Didn't like the sauce Little Caesar's still beat it better prices at Little Caesars

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
JD

Jesse Dominik

google
05.20.2017
5/5

Literally the best ingredients, fresh, hot, fast and cheap. What more can you ask for.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
CH

Christopher Hatten

google
05.01.2017
5/5

I highly recommend the Panzerotti. Its listed as an appetizer but you can add ingredients. It's basically a better version of a calzone.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
FT

Frank Tank

google
03.19.2017
5/5

Great homeade pizza. This is the only place where I would order pizza because the other places have a commercial taste.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
DV

Demetrios Varnasidis

google
03.05.2017
5/5

If I could give this place 6 stars I would. The Lasagna was to die for,everything was fresh and authentic. I found a new place to eat and Italian desserts are fresh !!! YUM

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
KW

Kyle Wilson

google
02.07.2017
5/5

Great pizza, pasta, and cannolis

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
HA

Hector Ayala

google
02.07.2017
1/5

Pizza was ok. Service was not good at all. We played for our drinks and didn't get them till we got our pizza which it was 25 minutes later. The restaurant is very outdated it needs much improvement.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
MR

Matt Rasmussen

google
01.14.2017
5/5

My roommate and I ordered a stuffed pizza for delivery while watching the OKC vs GS game (the game Curry hit that ridiculous 32 footer to win in OT). The price was fair, the delivery time was reasonable and the pizza was good. Wasn't the best pizza I ever had but I still thought it was very good. Overall a great experience and I would definitely order from there again.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
KB

Kathy B.

google
11.27.2016
5/5

Great food. Nice guys. Friendly drivers.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
AJ

Anthony Janke

google
11.24.2016
5/5

The pizza is always great, and I order here often. I've never had a problem.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
MB

Mike Bobnick

google
11.06.2016
5/5

Awesome pizza by Italian proprietors. Worth the time and effort to go here. Busy place, great pizza and other items.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
CN

Chris Neville

google
09.15.2016
5/5

Awesome local food. An icon in this neighborhood!

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
JP

Josh Perez

google
08.18.2016
1/5

Their robbing us with the prices. The slices are 1.75 and I got charged 6.51 for just 2 cheese slices. Some ain't right here.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
BT

Bill Tziforos

google
06.23.2016
5/5

Pizza was great. The owners are super nice.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
AM

Andrew Murdock

google
05.09.2016
5/5

Good pizza, friendly staff

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
AL

Andrew L

google
04.17.2016
5/5

Little Sicily is by far the best pizza in Schaumburg!! Very delicious pizza, panzerottis, french fries and appetizers!!! Fresh ingredients, great customer service, and reasonable prices cannot be beat!

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
DM

DAVID MATUSIEWICZ

google
04.16.2016
5/5

Probably the best thin crust pizza in the area. There roast beef and garlic pizza is by far the best and only place I will get it from. No one else matches it.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
pp

pilfer pwnage

google
03.21.2016
4/5

I like places that sell slices, and it's great pizza not super doughy

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
MD

Maria Dalesio

google
03.05.2016
5/5

Wonderful place too eat great Pizza🍕🍕

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
Jb

James beck

google
03.01.2016
4/5

If you're not hungry, just walk in and the aromas will have you ordering regardless.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
FL

Frank Long

google
02.10.2016
5/5

Awesome pizza and food here! A just try!

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant
SP

Shawn Phillips

google
01.16.2016
5/5

I have been going here for 15 years. that alone says something is special about this place. their food is consistently a high quality product. very flavorful, great textures. The owners are very hardworking and amazingly skilled chefs. This place you can't go wrong on ordering anything. the sandwiches, breads, desserts and pizza are some of the best in the country.

Little Sicily Pizzeria & Restaurant in Surprise

18795 N Reems Rd Ste 112, Surprise, AZ 85374-8686, Surprise

4.2
50

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 16235375900

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!